Man of Science, Man of Faith breast cancer thirties 30s 30's faith science church cat scan belief death

If you were a Lost fan and saw every episode (as I did), you might recall an episode titled “Man of Science, Man of Faith,” (S2, E1).

It was the first episode of season 2 and the episode where Jack, a surgeon, meets his future wife.  She is brought into the E.R. after a devastating car accident that leaves her paralyzed.  Jack plans to operate but tells her that the possibility of regaining function is almost nonexistent.  Jack’s father, a senior surgeon, witnesses this exchange and chastises his son for squelching his patient’s hope.  Jack barks that her spine is crushed and that any hope he’d be giving her would be false hope.  He performs the surgery to the best of his ability, but she is so damaged that he believes she is still paralyzed and that he was unable to fix her.  When he goes back to apologize and tell her she will never have feeling below her waist, she begins wiggling her toes.  Jack, who was previously only a man of science, realizes that science and faith merged to create a miracle.

My friend Nancy has known about my cancer since the beginning.  She watched me barely make it through harsh chemos.  She visited when I was giving myself daily injections of Neupogen as my white blood cell counts plummeted.  She came to say goodbye on the eves of major surgeries.  She brought dinners over to feed my children when I had I.V. bags full of fluid running into the Powerport in my chest and was vomiting so much that I could barely hold my head up.

She watched me spiral downward into a deep well of cancer.  And then she watched me slowly claw my way up to the surface again.

And somewhere in the midst of this, she came to my door with both fear and hope in her eyes.  She told me that her husband, Frank, had something show up on his CAT scan.

I knew that Frank’s hadn’t been feeling well.  I knew that he didn’t look well.  And when I last saw him, the yellow tint in his eyes did not go unnoticed.

She said that he was scheduled for surgery, but that God was good and that he would be fine.

As you may have guessed, Nancy is very religious and is outwardly so.  She has no qualms about sharing her beliefs.

Nor does she have any trouble with telling others to have hope and faith.  She has done this with me many times since my diagnosis.  She has even gone so far as to tell me in a roundabout way that when I am not doing well, it is because I am not trusting in God and not being faithful enough.

It is always a difficult thing for me to hear, especially during the times when I have felt my worst.  I’d be lying if I said the idea that I am responsible for the cancer for any reason is a tough pill to swallow.

But I listen and nod my head because I know Nancy is not saying these things to hurt my feelings.  I know she says them because her faith is so strong that she can’t see these situations from any other angle.

Frank’s surgery revealed a small tumor.  It was malignant.  They also found a small amount of cancer in one lymph node.  The good news was that the surgeon managed to get clean margins.

I was noticeably concerned, but Nancy reminded me that God is good and that the cancer was small and her husband would be fine.

Frank is a doctor and a man of the cloth.  Frank is both a man of science and a man of faith.  Usually.

When Frank started chemo, Nancy did her best to make healthy foods that Frank could tolerate.  She took care of him and they prayed together regularly.  They both had faith that everything would be fine.

Frank had a really difficult time with chemo and eventually decided that he’d had enough because it was making him so sick.  They repeated his scans and everything looked good.  So they both said “God is good” and made the decision to stop the chemo.  Frank was so sick from the chemo that he and Nancy thought it wasn’t worth continuing, especially when his scans were good and he had God protecting him.

I was reeling over this decision.  I insisted that Frank should continue to pray, but that he should also consider finishing the chemo.  I repeated that he would be horribly sick during chemo, but that he would feel better when it ended.  I said that it would be worth it in the end because it would give him the best shot at life.  I pleaded with them then — and many times since.

But they insisted that they were going to let God take care of it.  He didn’t need the harsh chemo.  He just needed to be faithful.

So time passed.  His scans were still good.  I insisted that he go back and finish, though.  But my friends told me that it wasn’t worth the side effects and that God was healing him.

And then he didn’t feel well.  He was having trouble eating.  He didn’t look good.  He was losing weight.

A few weeks later, Nancy said Frank had collapsed and they were going to the hospital for dehydration.  It was the second time in a month.

I suggested that she look into home I.V. hydration so he could avoid these hospital stays.  And I also pleaded with her to reconsider the chemo decision.  She said that it wasn’t open for discussion.  Frank did not want to get sicker with chemo and she wasn’t going to push it.  She still insisted that he would be fine.

He had to go back into the hospital last week.  Again for dehydration.  But this time the scan revealed something.  But she didn’t tell me about it.

She called tonight during dinner.  She asked about the times when I had home hydration because the hospital was giving her a hard time.  They told her that he would need to enroll in hospice and sign a DNR before they would start home I.V. hydration and was this what I had to do?

I told her that it wasn’t at all.  I signed a few forms at the Cancer Center and then a few more when the delivery truck and my nurse showed up at the door.  But it wasn’t hospice related.  And there was no DNR to sign.

The conversation haunted me.  Then I learned that Frank was no longer going upstairs.  Nancy was giving him sponge baths in the living room.  And a hospital bed had just been delivered.

I was sick to my stomach because I had been through this with loved ones before and I knew what it meant.

Nancy said that the latest scan revealed that the cancer had metastasized to his stomach.  That he has 3 months to live.  3 months.

They are scared.  And rightfully so.

And my heart aches for them because I love them both and I don’t want this disease to take Nancy’s husband.

I do believe in God and I do believe in the power of prayer.  But I also believe that modern medicine exists for a reason.

I  wish they could have found a way to balance medicine and faith.  I wish he had finished the chemo.  And I’m sure they do, too.


20 thoughts on “Man of Science, Man of Faith

    • Thank you, Clanmother. I know not everyone will like it, but it is what I am feeling at the moment, so I decided that I should post it if I want to keep my blog authentic.
      Thank you for your comment and your support!


      • I’m reminded of the story of the flood victim who refused to leave his house because he believed God would save him. He turned away a neighbor with a van, then a team in a rowboat, and finally a helicopter, each time proclaiming God would save him. When he drowned and arrived at the pearly gates, he ask St. Peter why God had not answered his prayers. Peter replied, “He sent you a van, a boat and a helicopter. He answered – you just weren’t listening.” Of course there is no guarantee the continued chemo would have changed Frank’s outcome, but sometimes I think we not only want an answer, but we want to dictate the terms. We need to be for flexible, be still, and listen for the answer that comes, not just the one we want. Sometimes it’s hard, but sometimes it’s better than we could have imagined.


  1. My heart goes out to “Frank” and “Nancy” its about conviction really and a test of ones faith, saddly we are all going to die we born to do so. “Frank now knows how he will die, sad, yes, unfortunate, yes and matter of faith no. Yes, I will pray that he passes we care and ease and that god grants him sanctuary for his faith. But praying to stop something that will happen regardless is often like pulling the sword from the stone many will try but it was only ment for one. Im not a religious person but I am a man of great faith. and a man of science as I depend daily on science to keep me alive and well physically and I depend on faith to help me deal with the burden of science.
    Much love and tender thought to you and those around you.


    • Thanks so much, Benjamin… I appreciate your comment and warm thoughts. Everything you said makes perfect sense — and was stated so poetically. I am so glad you have found a balance between science and faith. Warm thoughts are with you, too. xo


  2. I was raised in a religion whose doctrine treated trips to the doctor as a failure of faith. I love your quote, regarding such believers because it is so true… “But I listen and nod my head because I know Nancy is not saying these things to hurt my feelings. I know she says them because her faith is so strong that she can’t see these situations from any other angle.” How I wish she, and others like her, could extend their faith toward praying for doctors, nurses, drug manufacturers, and other loving caretakers, so God will be made manifest through them when medical treatment becomes a necessity. To paraphrase Betty Eady, author of “Embraced by the Light”, regarding the mechanics of healing, “We don’t deny the physical ailment, but rather we deny its ability to deprive us of our God given right to be healed of it.” However that healing is to take place, we must embrace it, and when we can’t do it on our own, we must do the next best thing and seek medical help. Thank you for sharing this sad, painful story. May God’s light and love continue to uplift you.


    • Thank you for taking the time to share your own story, and such a poignant comment. I like your words about healing and embracing the healing in whatever form it takes — so well stated.
      Thanks so much — your thoughtful words are always appreciated so much… xo


  3. Another really well written post. Please continue to write and inform your readers on the reality of cancer. It is all around us and few people are not affected in some way. Yet because of fear, ignorance and avoidance people turn away and choose not to get involved. They do not want to see. You are preparing them for life. Thank you.


    • Thank you, Westlake, for your comment and kind words…And for reminding me that what I am doing is worthwhile. I sometimes think that my energy should be spent elsewhere, especially when I know some of my thoughts may not be popular, but you remind me that though the realities of cancer may be uncomfortable, the truth is important.
      Thank you for lifting me up with your words… xo


  4. I feel sad for Frank and Nancy, this isn’t the outcome they were hoping for. I have learned that faith is a wonderful thing but cancer is such an evil adversary that faith alone is not enough. We need both, faith and science, and we have to use them hand in hand. Cancer requires the best that science can offer coupled with inner faith and faith from everyone around us and as you and I have experienced, sometimes that is still not enough. Thinking of you and sending love for you all.


  5. You have such a knack for keeping things real without being judgemental….your friend Nancy will need you more than she realizes very soon. She will likely be racked with guilt and remorse for not pushing Frank to continue with treatment -because it will always be unknown if it would have made The Difference or not. She is lucky to count you as a friend.


    • Thank you for your words, Denise. Nancy has been a good friend to me, so I only hope I can be as good a friend to her in the coming months. I sincerely hope she will feel no guilt because I’m sure the pain of the loss will be more than enough to bear — and who knows, maybe the chemo wouldn’t have made the difference? I always say that I wish I had a crystal ball with this disease. I think the decisions — and being okay with your choices — are sometimes the hardest part. You are kind to say that she is lucky to have me as a friend — I am fortunate, too, so I will work on returning the favor,
      Thank you, Denise… xo


  6. Pingback: An Update on Frank and Nancy | cancerinmythirties

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s